‘Do Koreans eat dogs?‘ and Western hypocrisy
How Koreans treat dogs
This is the horrible life Kimchi Man’s dog has :)

Having a Korean boyfriend means getting a few question asked over and over again, every time people find out who you are dating.

“Is he from North or South Korea?”. South of course. “Aren’t they really poor there?” You’re thinking of North again. “Are Koreans Buddhists?” Most are atheists actually, but there is fair share of other religions represented.

And of course, the unavoidable,

Do Koreans really eat dogs?”

Now, other’s ignorance can be mildly annoying. But I am painfully aware of how many things I am ignorant about, so this is actually not the reason why that question annoys me so.

No, it annoys me because of the underlying criticism. It is a loaded question, with asker being ready to judge as soon as he or she hears the answer.

Now, as the situation stands, majority of Koreans haven’t tried dog meat. Even fewer eat it regularly. There is a large group of Koreans that is very strongly against eating dog meat. Then there is yet another group who doesn’t eat dog meat themselves but feel others should have the right to do so if they wish. And yet another group, albeit a lot smaller one, who believe it is an important part of Korean history and as such should be preserved.

Another thing to keep in mind is that the dogs they do eat are not pet dogs. It’s not like Koreans get hungry someday, see they forgot to stock the fridge and decide that their beloved pet would make a nice roast. They eat the so called livestock dogs, which are a different breed of dogs and are bred just like any other cattle humans eat.

But as far as the dog-eating itself goes, I have to ask, why not?

“Gasp!” you might say, “she promotes eating puppies!”

Not at all, I would never eat dog meat, but I know why not. What I am wondering is, do you?

Dogs are very intelligent you might say, they feel love, fear, pain, just like we do. They get attached to humans. Well, so do pigs. And did you know that cows have best friends, and if they get separated from each other they show signs of great stress? I bet you didn’t think you’re eating someone’s best friend.

Cute Piglet

Just in the 2011 U.S. exported 1.75 BILLION tons of pork and over 900 million tons of beef. Exported. That doesn’t even include the amount that was eaten there. Just compare that to 8,500 tons of dog meat that are consumed per year in Korea and you will see it is a staggering difference.

Of course, this is obviously not aimed at vegetarians, or people who are aware of the hypocrisy. It is aimed at those who say: “They eat dog meat!? How repulsive and primitive!” while chewing on their pork chop.

So why don’t I eat dog meat? ONLY because of the culture I’ve been brought up in. I view dogs as pets and nothing more, I would be unable to stop thinking of them that way throughout the whole meal and it would certainly ruin my appetite, if not make me downright nauseated. On the other hand when I bite into beef I don’t even think about where it came from, since it’s been presented to me as food since I was a small child. It’s nothing more than social conditioning. But to think that makes me morally superior to Koreans would take a very heavy twisting of reality.

 

Edit: 21th of July, 2013. All opinions and comments are welcome! However, please stay on topic. Any comments that are off topic will be removed from this point on.

 

 

You might also like:

Koreans date vegetarians Korean Jindo dog Do Koreans eat dogs
Do Korean guys date vegetarian and vegan girls? Korean Jindo dog What does it mean to be Korean?

79 responses to “‘Do Koreans eat dogs?‘ and Western hypocrisy”

  1. 애니 Avatar
    애니

    I feel the same way about the issue. Same with the whole “Japanese eating dolphins! They’re beasts!” situation. Yes I love animals and wouldn’t dare to eat a dog or a dolphin, but that’s my own decision, and I think it’s only fair that others have the right to make their own decisions too. The only thing that would make me question or call out on the issue is how the animal is being treated. If they are abused or inhumanely slaughtered, it really irks me out. People need to eat, make profit, but would it really kill them to be humane? I don’t know, that’s just my own opinion. There’s questionable cuisines throughout the whole entire world, I don’t see why everyone has to make a big deal over it, people in India or Africa probably look at our ‘normal’ meals and laugh.

  2. Tina Avatar
    Tina

    I dont get it this activist. I have a korean friend and someday I told her that in brazil we eat chicken heart and yeah, I love chicken heart but she was chocked and then she told and explain me very well that in korea some people eat dog meat but she not and I thought that´s is not fair to a dog be killed to be eat but I eat chicken. It´s just a culture differences, and we need to accept. We cant say asians are bad becayse they eat dogs and scorpions and bla bla bla and be offend if someday they say brazilians are bad people because we eat chicken heart. It´s childish come here and make a discution when you cant do nothing. Or you can help in a animal shelter in your city and help and give love to the animals you can help , since you cant save all the animals in the world. if i could do that, i would have a zoo in my home, I just have 7 now.

  3. Jeff Avatar
    Jeff

    I’ve noticed with animal rights activists, that they frequently place more emotion, more passion, when the targets are east asians than white europeans. For example, the clubbing of baby seals in Canada, the skinning of deer and other furry animals in the US to be hanged on walls as a mantelpiece – sure, activists campaign against it, but the passion is largely absent and restrained. Civil, if you will.

    Now compare things like whaling. Indeed it’s a great example, because Scandanavian nations do it, Japan does it. who gets all the abuse, the pressure? It’s not Norway or Iceland.

    Recently some farmers in Switzerland said it was no big deal eating dogs. Yes, even pet dogs they looked after for a while. I didn’t hear folk like Bridget Pimm and spraypaintedsoul responding with venom as if they had just killed their own children. Yet that is what those of East asian origin face when committing the same acts.

    1. oegukeen Avatar

      I’m also confused why people go through trouble of doing activism half-way across the world when there is so much they could do where they are. But they probably have their reasons.

  4.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Dear god I wish if people had to start an argument it could actually have some relevant information included. Some Koreans eat dogs the same way same westerners eat chicken therefore we shouldn’t judge them any differently to how we judge ourselves. It’s exactly the same thing except we have an image of a dog that can make us attached to it, we see them as pets, some people see chickens as pets, cows as pets. The way they’re breeded, looked after, cooked is not relevant to this article so go somewhere that IS relevent. Pack it in attacking the writer, her article made perfect sense and there is nothing wrong with what she’s said.

    1. oegukeen Avatar

      Hello,

      and thank you for this comment. I really appreciate it because I was starting to doubt if the message I was trying to send was really that much unclear. I am relieved to see that you got my point crystal clear.

      If they were unable to understand when I tried to explain it, hopefully they will get it from your comment.

    2. spraypaintedsoul Avatar
      spraypaintedsoul

      actually ‘anonymous’ haha in other words author ;)
      although i oppose the killing of chickens, beef, etc. dog and cat meat is 5x worse. they are tortured, whereas we have laws ENFORCED to promote painfree deaths (whatever that may be) in korea and china etc. they are killed in a way that promotes pain for a better tasting meat.

      these are animals that whether they’re pets or not, they’re being killed in disgusting ways and until you see it you can’t write an article all artsy fartsy about how wrong it is people judge them.

      DOG MEAT IS FUCKING ILLEGAL. for a reason. we judge other criminals so why should those funding a cruel illegal trade (in majority of pets) be exempt from our judgement. – AS I SAID ABOVE.

      stop sending yourself fake comments and admit you made a mistake. my friends and i followed your account because we thought you were a cool blog but each of us and many more have unfollowed :)

      1. oegukeen Avatar

        As a blogger on WordPress you should know full well that every comment’s IP address is visible, so I can’t comment on my own posts and pretend it is someone else.

        Also, I see how many followers I have, you have no way of knowing how many there are, so your accusations of losing followers are equally ridiculous and unfounded.

        Dog meat is not illegal in Korea. It is not governed by law at all, unlike beef and pork. Torturing animals IS illegal. Get your facts straight. I even provided the link to that law a few comments above. And, for the last time, that is off topic, that is not the theme nor purpose of my article.

        Attacking me and our blog instead of attacking my opinions is clear proof that you are losing this discussion.

      2. Lily Avatar
        Lily

        spraypaintedsoul why are you still banging on about the way animals are killed and illegalities and false accusations? (it was me Lily who wrote the first comment you absolute cretin). If you have unfollowed Oeugukeen’s blog I’m fairly sure she’d be over the friggin moon to be rid of an annoyance like you anyway. Get out and don’t comment back because anyone who has sense will just see it as a desperate attempt to prove right an irrelevant point.

  5. spraypaintedsoul Avatar
    spraypaintedsoul

    dogs are skinned and boiled alive, so i do think it’s fair there is a criticism there. it is illegal for a reason in most countries but i do agree with your points about all animals being unique and able to feel pain.

    its ignorant that we’d choose to value one life but torture anothers. hence why i’m vegetarian, in all honesty any meat eating is just a culture raised thing, and it’s not necessary to eat meat.

    my problem however, is how they are raised. animals that are more deserving of grass and sunshine than any others, i.e. pigs and cows are placed into tiny cages that compress them and forcefed with pipes until their legs break from the weight. they are dragged and beaten until they physically cry with tears and they are inhumanely butchered.

    none of it’s right in my opinion. whether you’re eating a dog or a cow or a pig. respect the life that animal had no choice in suffering through, perhaps consider a more fair option.

    1. oegukeen Avatar

      You make very good points. The skinning and boiling alive is illegal in Korea as well since 2007.

      I agree completly that all animals that are kept by humans, whether they are pets, zoo animals or waiting to become food need to have good quality lives where both their physical and psychological wellbeing are considered.

      However, this is a blog about dating Korean guys so I am just concentrating on that issue, as you called it the ignorance, that one animal life is valuable and other is not when passing the blame to Koreans.

      It’s just something that happened to me personally a few times when I told people where my boyfriend is from.

      Of course there are many important issues to talk about that are not only concerning Koreans, nor animals, but this is Loving Korean after all :)

      1. spraypaintedsoul Avatar
        spraypaintedsoul

        many drugs are illegal worldwide but that doesn’t stop it happening. it just gets sneakier. i agree 100% with your points but some don’t seem fully researched and although i understand you are addressing the judgement applied to stigmas e.g. from eating dog.

        touching on a topic that is clearly very sensitive and having dogs close to me taken for this cruel industry i find it difficult to simply believe people who are funding this industry are simply fine to do as they please and not be judged.

        we judge drug addicts and alcoholics, we say that their actions are wrong and illegal, and i believe the same must be done to those who fund the illegal trading of animals that is against the law for a reason.

        1. oegukeen Avatar

          I still don’t understand how this has anything to do with the article I wrote.

          1. spraypaintedsoul Avatar
            spraypaintedsoul

            you’re saying that cruelty when slaughtering the animals is illegal, but so are drugs. something being against the law really makes no difference and you’re just being blind to all the other topics you’ve touched upon in your ‘innocent’ article.

            you’ve offended many with a belief that animals deserve rights, you’ve offended any who believe that governments are incapable of dealing with all the issues at this time across the globe.

          2. oegukeen Avatar

            “… something being against the law really makes no difference …”
            I’m sorry, WHAT?

            This is what I wrote just 2 comments above:
            “I agree completely that all animals that are kept by humans, whether they are pets, zoo animals or waiting to become food need to have good quality lives where both their physical and psychological wellbeing are considered.”
            and that offends people who believe animals deserve rights? Once again, WHAT?

            You and Ms. Brigit Pimm are truly blinded by your cause and can’t seem to understand what is being said here.

            But from the other comments I see that majority of other readers get it.

            I REALLY try to answer all the comments on this site. I’m sorry, but that just won’t be possible here anymore. I will just go use the time I have to answer other comments on other posts in constructive manner. Our loyal readers deserve it more.

  6. bulma Avatar
    bulma

    Ahjussi,why so serious?it’s not like every single koreans eat dogs….i bet people who eat dogs they dont keep it as a pet…:-)

    Time to eat ramen…chicken ramen please!

Leave a reply to spraypaintedsoul Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Loving Korean

If Korean guy prefers Korean girls do I stand a chance

a place to read about learning Korean language, admiring rich and long Korean culture, and answering your questions about dating Korean guys, written by a diverse group of people. Join us as we have fun and learn about South Korea!

Let’s connect